Buenafe v. Kiehm, 125 Haw.30, 251 P.3d 47 (ICA 2011)

Under Hawaii statute, before a claim for medical malpractice can be filed in court, the plaintiff first has to file a claim with the Medical Inquiry Conciliation Panel (formerly the Medical Claims Conciliation Panel). The claim must be in writing.

In this case, the plaintiff filed suit after filing a claim with the Medical Claims Conciliation Panel. The written claim submitted to the panel failed to allege that there was a lack of informed consent to a surgical procedure. The trial court granted partial summary judgment against the plaintiff that dismissed the claim of lack of informed consent. The ICA upheld the trial court’s decision.

This decision is a red flag to plaintiffs’ counsel to make sure that all claims are identified in writing in the mandatory administrative proceeding. Failure to do so could lead to the harsh result of any new claim being barred.

Contact Jan Weinberg for a FREE consultation to review your case. Jan Weinberg will meet you at the hospital, your home, or office.